Others mocked the movement’s image, saying separatists in cowboy hats had already “lost the PR battle.”
Some pointed out the movement’s fragmentation, with “at least nine separatist groups” already competing for attention.
Still, the frustration runs deep.
"The election was a referendum on Alberta’s place in Canada,” said one user. “And the country voted to keep ignoring us.”
With Alberta solidly Conservative and the federal government firmly Liberal, many feel shut out of national decisions — especially around energy, taxes, and regulation.
“What would it take for Alberta to feel heard?” asked another. Suggestions ranged from pipeline approvals to equalization reform.
Even those who don’t back separation say the anger is real — and growing.
Some vented about Pierre Poilievre’s campaign, calling it “slogans, no substance,” while others slammed Prime Minister Carney’s early moves as undemocratic. “No budget, no Parliament. Just media and executive orders,” one said.
While few believe full separation will happen, many on the forum say the current path isn’t working.
As one put it: “True independence might be out of reach, but Ottawa’s got to stop pretending this frustration will just go away.”
Find the full Agriville thread here, and join the discussion!