Tariff System Fails to Protect U.S. Producers
U.S. beef imports increased by 24% in 2024, with Brazil, Uruguay, and Australia as top contributors. Brazilian imports rose by 60%, Uruguayan imports by 76%, and Australian imports by 67%. Despite tariff and quota measures, these imports are displacing domestic production.
Under the current system, Uruguay and Brazil exceeded their quotas significantly. Uruguay imported 284 million pounds of beef, surpassing its 44-million-pound limit by a factor of five. Brazil imported over 500 million pounds above its quota, with minimal penalties.
“The 26.4% over-quota tariff rate is ineffective in protecting our domestic beef industry,” said Bill Bullard, CEO of R-CALF USA. He warned that importers are dominating the U.S. market, threatening local producers.
The trade deficit in beef has grown drastically, nearly doubling from 687 million pounds in 2023 to 1.5 billion pounds in 2024. This mirrors the collapse of the U.S. sheep industry, where unchecked imports captured 70% of the domestic lamb market.
Between 2017 and 2022, the U.S. lost 107,000 cattle operations. If this trend continues, domestic beef production may struggle to compete, increasing dependence on foreign imports.
To sustain the cattle industry, stronger measures are essential, such as revising the tariff rate system and limiting imports. Safeguarding domestic production is key to ensuring a stable food supply and protecting U.S. producers.