Compared to last year, pre-planting relative financial risk between corn, cotton, and soybean production has changed for many mid-south crop producers. The change in pre-planting financial risk can be illustrated using projected crop insurance prices and crop budgets for 2024 and 2025. Crop insurance prices in this analysis were determined February 1-28 and crop budgets were University of Tennessee Crop Budgets for non-irrigated production. For ease of comparison, actual production history (APH) is unchanged between years and is equal to the target yield in the crop budgets.
Table 1 shows the difference between the crop insurance revenue guarantee for corn, cotton, and soybeans at a 75% buy-up coverage in 2024 and 2025. The crop insurance coverage per bushel or pound is the revenue guarantee divided by the APH. The crop insurance coverage level for corn increased slightly from $3.50/bu to $3.53/bu; however, coverage was reduced for cotton ($0.62/lb to $0.52/lb) and soybeans ($8.66/bu to $7.91/bu). At the same time, from 2024 and 2025, cost of production changed by +/- 2-3% depending on the commodity (Table 2). Cost of production will vary based on geographic location, targeted yield, and production practices.
Cost of production should be estimated for two separate measures—cash costs and economic costs. Cash costs are expenses that need to be paid during the production and marketing year, while economic costs include cash costs as well as ownership and other non-cash costs. In the short run, farms can operate covering cash costs, however, economic costs need to be covered for the operation to remain viable in the long-term. The cash and economic cost per bushel or pound are calculated by dividing cost by target yield (breakeven cash and economic cost per bushel or pound).
The crop insurance coverage per bushel or pound divided by the cash or economic cost provides an estimate of the relative financial risk by year and commodity. The analysis in Table 2 shows that in 2024, 74-75% of the economic cost of production for corn, cotton, and soybeans was covered by Revenue Protection crop insurance, compared to 76% for corn, 65% for cotton, and 67% for soybeans in 2025. For the start of the 2025 crop year, the financial risk mitigated by crop insurance favors corn over soybeans and cotton.